Movie Review: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (2010)

Twilight hype continues to rage around the world with the release of the third film in the “Saga” — Eclipse.  I just went to see it with my sister who is visiting from out of town.  She’s not a Twilight “fan” per se, but she was excited.  I on the other hand, having read the book at the beginning of the year, was a little more ambivalent about the whole thing, but still wanted to see it.

Well, the third instalment of Twilight fever was a bit of a “meh” affair.  It picks up where the second film left off, with Bella Swan (Kristen Stewart) in blissful love with her vampire boyfriend Edward Cullen (Robert Pattinson), and neglecting her werewolf best friend Jacob Black (Taylor Lautner), who has a hopeless crush on her.  But all is not well because people are dying under mysterious circumstances in Seattle and it appears Bella is the ultimate target.  Who could it be?  Trust me, it’s bleedingly obvious.

Director David Slade (who directed the impressive 30 Days of Night and the excellent Hard Candy) probably did all he could with this one.  While it contained the most climatic dramatic and action sequences of the series thus far, Eclipse had me yawning and laughing (at the unintentional humour) more regularly than I should have.

The novel version of Eclipse is referred to by many Twilight fans as the best of the Saga, though I personally thought it was very long and not much happened until the very end.  Plus that Bella is really annoying!  So to be honest I thought the movie was better than the book because it only took up 2 hours as opposed to a couple of weeks and still managed to essentially cover all the main points of the novel.

By now we’re all familiar with the core characters and their traits, so we don’t find out anything new about them.  What we have is more of the same old from the last two films (sexual tension and corny dialogue), but even more dramatic and intense.

Bella continues to be torn between two “men” who love her and can’t decide what she wants to do with her life.  I’ve been a fan of Kristen Stewart since Into the Wild, but there’s no denying that she was irritating in this one.  Her acting was better (she showed more range than that singular “I’ve got something stuck in my throat” expression) but it didn’t make Bella a more sympathetic character.  There were many whispers of “slut” throughout the cinema during a couple of scenes!

Rob Patz’s Edward Cullen takes a bit of a back seat in this one, even though he has more screen time than in New Moon.  He is still disgustingly sweet and overprotective, but he felt strangely hollow.  It may have something to do with the constant strain on his face and in his voice.  Give the poor guy some metamucil.

Again, it’s up to Taylor Lautner’s Jacob Black and his ripped bod to save the show.  Lautner has some horribly melodramatic lines, but to his credit, he manages to pull most them off without generating laughter.  He’s the only central character out of the three to develop any sort of connection with me.

The returning cast (such as Billy Burke, Anna Kendrick, Dakota Fanning, Ashley Greene and Kellan Lutz etc) do a solid job with their smaller roles, and it was good to find out the back stories of some of the vampires and werewolves through flashbacks.  However, the casting of Bryce Dallas Howard as the villain Victoria was a terrible choice to replace Rachelle Lefevre.  She has the same long red curls but has zero menace.  A real disappointment considering what a fantastic actress she is.

To sum it all up, Eclipse is a passable effort for the third film of a blockbuster franchise.  Nothing about it is great, but I can’t exactly point to anything that was done too badly.  It gives fans what they want — which is more mushy stuff between the three leads, plus more vampire/werewolf action — but it’s unlikely to turn non-fans into new fans of the Saga.

3 stars out of 5

PS: It was interesting to see several characters sporting Justin Bieber haircuts.

8 thoughts on “Movie Review: The Twilight Saga: Eclipse (2010)”

  1. Was soooo disappointed! Love the third book the best but disliked the boring lack lustre movie. Am a huge Twilight fan which makes this all so disappointing for me to even write!

  2. I love Kristen Stewart as Bella – so please do not bag her!!! Love Rob but he didn’t shine like the sparkles of his skin in this movie (unlike in the first movie). In this third movie it was easy to see that Jacob was the star and made it worthwhile to sit through the seemingly very long two and a bit hours.

    1. I am a fan of Kristen as well and I can’t think of anyone who would make a better Bella — but she doesn’t exactly exhibit much emotion apart from lust, guilt and angst…

      I thought it was interesting how director David Slade really toned down on the sparkles this time…I was curious as to the graduation scene when the whole family was in attendance but it seemed like no one sparkled…

  3. I just finished seeing Eclipse on Tuesday night. I am a HUGE fan of the books but not so much with the movies. The third movie went off track too far from the book. It wouldn’t have been a bad movie if I hadn’t of read the books besides the fact that Jacob(the werewolf) acted like a love sick, bitter whiner throughout the movie. Also, Kristen Stuart is what I find to be an absolutely terrible actress throughout the series, and Jacob should have been played by a real man, not some little boy who has probably never experienced real love in his life enough to understand it. He was not a believable actor for the part, and neither is Bella. And once more, I wish this series was a little more on the adult side because generally, these kids are too young to even know what they are doing and to know what TRUE love is, and that is what the books are all about. I give it a 2 thumbs down for all twilight book readers, and a 3/5 for all of you who have not read the books.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *