Talk about a letdown.
You have Diablo Cody, the creator of cult favourite Juno, which just won her the Oscar for Best Original Screenplay (and also the award-winning TV show The United States of Tara). You have Amanda Seyfried, the up-and-coming star of Mean Girls and Mamma Mia!. You have director Karyn Kusama, who was at the helm for Æon Flux (I know), but also the critically acclaimed Girl Fight. And of course, there’s Megan Fox, who is widely regarded as the most desirable woman on the freaking planet.
On paper, Jennifer’s Body looks like a sure winner. But somehow, the film received a lukewarm reception and totally bombed out. It will go straight to DVD in Australia early next year.
After seeing it, I can kinda understand why.
As per usual, I’m not revealing the any more of the plot than necessary. Just know it is set in a high school and is a horror comedy about two teenage girls. One good thing is that the previews are somewhat misleading and don’t give away too much.
In a way, I can see where the movie was coming from. At its heart, Jennifer’s Body is a very dark black comedy which pays tribute to the old school horror movies (and has a certain 80s feel to it). There are parts that are genuinely funny if you appreciate dark humour (I certainly do), and there are a couple of scenes which may give you a fright, or at least make you cringe in disgust.
However, watching it, I got the distinct feeling that Cody deliberately set out to make a ‘cult’ movie – and that just doesn’t work. Movies are given the distinguished ‘cult’ status by the fans. When you try too hard to make a film quirky and wacky, it just gets weird – but without the accompanying unintended laughs. There were so many WTF moments in Jennifer’s Body, but they weren’t necessarily good WTF moments. Don’t get me wrong, Cody is a skilled screenwriter who writes witty, crisp dialogue and creates great characters, but it feels all too polished and packaged.
It’s a difficult film to rate because it has some great elements to it. It’s sexy, hip and stylish and knows how to manipulate the audience, especially teenage boys (whom they probably thought would flock to see Fox and Seyfried get it on). The performances are solid, especially Seyfried, who manages to pull off an ‘average’ teenage girl convincingly. And Megan Fox surprised me with her acting ability. Yes, she was playing a skanky, bitchy slut of a girl so it might not have been a stretch for her (think Eminem in 8 Mile), but she was actually very good.
On the other hand, Jennifer’s Body just wasn’t that enjoyable. There are solid moments but it’s not particularly scary nor particularly funny. It was a little all over the place (though this was probably intentional). It’s unfortunate because I think they had something going here with the premise and the concept, but the pieces just didn’t fit together for some reason.
2.5 stars out of 5!